Alien Oceans: The Search for Life in the Depths of Space
by Kevin Peter Hand
Princeton Univ. Press, 2020
hardcover, 304 pp., illus.
Last week, the Government Accountability Office published its annual assessment of cost and schedule major NASA programs. Much of the interest in the report focused on NASA’s exploration programs, which are years behind schedule and billions over budget, but the GAO also cited an issue of a different kind with a planetary science mission, Europa Clipper. That mission is facing a $250 million cost increase because the spacecraft may be ready too soon: because of a congressional mandate to launch the mission on the Space Launch System, Europa Clipper isn’t expected to launch until 2025, even though the spacecraft itself will be ready in 2023. The additional money will be needed to cover spacecraft storage, workforce costs, and other impacts to the mission while it waits for an SLS rocket.
Europa Clipper is something of an unusual mission in any case. While NASA was reticent to start the mission, citing the cost impact the multibillion-dollar mission would have on its overall planetary science portfolio, Congress added money to the agency’s budget to both start the mission earlier than NASA wanted and develop it faster than desired. (It also added the provision requiring the SLS launch, arguing it would allow the spacecraft to reach Jupiter faster than alternative launch options.) That was thanks primarily to a single member of Congress, Rep. John Culberson (R-TX), although Congress continued its support for the mission even after Culberson lost reelection in 2018.
Despite that history, the science case for a mission like Europa Clipper is strong, as outlined in Alien Oceans by Kevin Peter Hand, a scientist at JPL. Europa is among the “ocean worlds” in the outer solar system, which includes Saturn’s moons Enceladus and Titan, that may have subsurface oceans of liquid water that could harbor life. He thinks those worlds are better places to look for life beyond Earth than Mars, which lost its once hospitable surface conditions billions of years ago. “I want to find life that is alive today, life that is extant as opposed to extinct.”
For much of the book, Hand goes through our knowledge of those worlds, outlining the evidence of subsurface oceans from spacecraft missions, then examining what it takes for these hospitable worlds to be inhabitable. That includes some informed speculation about how life could thrive there, including advanced or even intelligent life, similar to another recent book (see “Review: Imagined Life”, The Space Review, October 28, 2019).
Hand believes the Europa in particular is the best place to look for life, although he also supports missions to Enceladus as well as the Dragonfly mission to Titan that NASA selected for development last year. Curiously, there’s very little discussion of Europa Clipper in the book. Hand calls it a “fantastic” mission, but only spends about a paragraph discussing the science it will perform; ESA’s JUICE mission to Europa and the other Galilean moons of Jupiter, also scheduled for launch in the early 2020s, also gets only a brief discussion. (Culberson’s role in accelerating Europa Clipper’s development is literally relegated to a footnote.)
Those will be followed by proposed lander missions and, perhaps, a submersible that drills through the ice to reach that subsurface ocean, kilometers below the surface. That exploration may take decades or even a century to carry out, he acknowledges near the end of the book. “Building robotic spacecraft to explore the solar system is the modern analog of building cathedrals,” he writes. “They take time, commitment, and vision.” Hopefully the Europans are patient.